BURNT BY STOCKS : STUDENT LOST $700,000 IN 3 MONTHS

Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
#1
I am posting this up for the sake of the newcomers, esp students and retirees to be careful.

This news isn't a decade ago, it happened only in 2007, barely 3 years had passed.

Read and digest the wisdom of the article slowly.


If I could save one soul, its enough for my effort in posting this up already.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Student on winning stock market streak, then he loses dad's life savings

OCT LAST YEAR: Just a student in Australia, he makes $80,000 from trading
DEC LAST YEAR: Back in S'pore after exams, he role-plays trading & makes an imaginary $100,000 on 1st day & $110,000 on 2nd day
DEC-JAN: Convinces dad to give him life savings of $300,000. But he loses it & the $80,000
Feb: Girlfriend dumps him. He stops trading for 2 weeks.
FEB: He puts money on stocks of 9 companies when market reopens after Chinese New Year

By Maureen Koh
The Electric New Paper

EVEN before he graduated from an Australian university, this Singapore engineering student earned $80,000 in a month.

Mr Chan (we are not giving his full name to protect his identity) did not have a job.

The 27-year-old was betting on the Singapore stock market, and managed to pick the shares whose prices rocketed in the recent bull run.


Buoyed by the success, his father was convinced that his only son had a Midas touch. So, the 67-year-old former sailor, who runs a shop selling women's clothes in Chinatown, gave his son $300,000 - his whole life savings - to invest in shares.

That was a couple of months ago.

Today, Mr Chan has not only lost all his father's savings, he has incurred another $320,000 in trading losses.

When the global market went through a sudden meltdown last week, so did his luck and fortune.

EVERYTHING BOMBED

In just two days, Mr Chan chalked up a few hundred thousand dollars in losses when The Straits Times Index (STI) dived by 75.9 points on 27 Feb and another 127.87 points (the steepest dive in 20 years) on 28 Feb.

He said: 'Everything bombed in just 48 hours. My life, my future... and now, even my parents could lose their home.'

In three short months of trading, Mr Chan has lost about $700,000.

Although the market has regained some of its earlier losses this week, the recovery means little to him.

Mr Chan was dabbling in high-risk contra trading, where you buy and sell the same shares within three days, putting up no money and earning the profits when share prices go up. But investors can lose money when the stock market is having a downturn, and they will have to pay the losses to their stockbrokers within days.

Mr Chan bought heavily into popular counters such as DBS, UOB, Capitaland and even China stocks such as Longcheer Holdings, and hoped to sell them for a gain before the usual deadline.

But as the market dipped suddenly and he could not afford to pay and keep all the shares, he had to make up for all the losses he incurred during his trading period.

Even after exhausting his previous winnings, his father's savings, and loans from friends, he still owes two of his remisiers more than $200,000.

To add to his woes, his girlfriend of eight years has also walked out on him, disappointed by how his gambling had cost him dearly.

Most of his friends are also avoiding his calls or finding excuses not to meet him. Word has gone around that he is desperate for money because he has already borrowed some $70,000 from 20 of his friends.

Mr Chan said: 'No one can blame them for avoiding me. Thankfully, I still have my parents on my side, otherwise I'd probably have gone insane.'

To help him, his father is prepared to move to a smaller home if needed. While the family is scrambling to raise the money to clear the debt, Mr Chan admitted he had entertained thoughts of filing for bankruptcy.

He said: 'I was told if I did that, it'd be tough for me to find a decent job.'

During the interview with The New Paper on Sunday, Mr Chan became rather agitated and restless when he related his problems. 'Look, it's fine if it's just me, but I've got to think of my parents,' he said.

This is a far cry from October last year when he was preparing for his final-year examination in Perth.

At a group study session, one of his Singaporean classmates checked on his own trading account and shouted happily when he made a few thousand dollars.

Mr Chan recalled: 'I was hooked from the minute he started talking about how easy it was to make a profit.

''He encouraged me to do likewise and even suggested that I start off with contra trading since I didn't have much cash.'

Mr Chan then contacted a cousin, who had an online trading account in Singapore, and asked him to buy some shares he selected.

He said: 'I made $23,000 by the end of the first week and my friends started calling me Prince Midas.

'I guess I sort of got carried away when I made another killing of about $30,000. I got bolder and by the time I stopped because of the exams, I was richer by $80,000.'

Mr Chan returned to Singapore in early December after his examinations and shared the news with his father and 58-year-old mother. They were impressed with his 'windfall'.

Still, he insisted that it was not the 'easy cash' but boredom that got him trading again.

He said: 'I wanted to take a break for a couple of months before looking for a job, so I was idling during the day when my parents and my girlfriend were at work. 'I was surfing the Internet when I decided to check out the SGX homepage. I randomly picked a few companies and the chart pattern I saw was definitely encouraging.'

He started to monitor the shares, and role-played as if he had bought heavily into them.

When the STI closed on the first day, he had made an imaginary $100,000; on the second day, it was another $110,000 'win'.

'I was, like, geez! If only I had dealt in real money. Then it occurred to me, maybe this is my calling. If I were good, I could afford to let my parents retire comfortably, have a lavish wedding, and upgrade my Honda Civic.'

Over dinner that night, Mr Chan shared his plan with his parents and asked them if they would like to pool in their money.

He said: 'My father told me, no risk, no gain.' Two days later, the senior Mr Chan transferred $300,000, his whole life savings, to his son's bank account.

Flushed with cash, Mr Chan was able to open trading accounts with three stockbroking firms. He was so focused on his new 'responsibility' that he 'ate, slept and breathed stocks'.

From analysing companies' chart patterns to buying stocks after a fall, Mr Chan traded shares of up to six companies at one go.

'I thought I was so smart to diversify... you know what they say, never put all your eggs into one basket,' he said.

But when he registered the first negative return, Mr Chan 'freaked out'.

'I felt it should not have happened because people were making money.'

The $28,000 loss was just the beginning of his nightmare. He said: 'I lost control. I could not afford to lose the money. My family does not belong to the high-income strata.'

His confidence level dipped further when he kept picking 'the bad eggs'.

As his stocks dipped further, he started to panic and began to ask his friends for loans.

To help him, his girlfriend applied for four bank overdraft facilities and even maxed the limit on five credit cards.

She was the only one who knew the true extent of his losses.

Mr Chan said: 'I couldn't tell my parents. But my girlfriend was there for me... until she could not take it anymore.

He covered his face for some seconds and said quietly: 'I've let her down. Really.'

In his bid to win his girlfriend and his money back, Mr Chan said he stopped trading for about two weeks, but continued to monitor the charts.

Hoping to recover some of his earlier losses, he set his sight on the stocks of nine companies when the market re-opened after the Chinese New Year.

But Mr Chan ended up suffering $100,000 in paper losses and $220,000 in contra trading.

He said: 'I went in for the kill, only to find I could barely stay alive less than five trading days later. My loved ones may now have to 'die together' with me.'

He added: 'I don't even know if I have the money to return to the university for my convocation end of this month. I can't bring myself to think of what's next.'

Reply
#2
To avoid a similar mistake as Chan's, we should not follow his silly and naive example to trade/buy stocks - same-day trade, contra trade, or short-term trade - without the necessary funds to take up the contract or pay for it. We should not make short-term bets - whether long or short - on stocks just based on the price charts, news, market rumours, others' recommendations, etc., without first convincing ourselves on the fundemental investment merits. We should also bear in mind that short-term volatility of the overall market and individual stocks bring added risks for those who choose to invest or trade in stocks as short-term bets.

I would much prefer to invest in stocks for the longer term and treat them as partial ownership in the underlying businesses. If I choose my stocks well and buy into them with a good margin-of-safety - i.e. the entry price should be at a good discount to the fair intrinsic value - I should be able to gain from my investments over time, and definitely avoid Chan's fate.
Reply
#3
Don't ever contra !

Should scrap the T+3 system...
Disclaimer: Please feel free to correct any error in my post. I am not liable for anything. Do your own research and analysis. I do NOT give buy or sell calls and stock tips. Buy and sell at your risk. I am not a qualified financial adviser so I do not give any advice. The postings reflects my own personal thoughts which may or may not be accurate.
Reply
#4
Agreed...So many fellow friends bought contra and got burnt, luckily they'll not playing up to the tens thousands. Hopefully, they learn.

Quote:Should scrap the T+3 system...
To entice the contra players, some remisers offer T+5 for payments... Dodgy
Reply
#5
Classic example of someone who can't differentiate between true merit and sheer luck.

A rising tide raises all boats. It is only when it recedes, then we know who is swimming naked.
Reply
#6
(17-01-2011, 11:09 PM)dydx Wrote: To avoid a similar mistake as Chan's, we should not follow his silly and naive example to trade/buy stocks - same-day trade, contra trade, or short-term trade - without the necessary funds to take up the contract or pay for it. We should not make short-term bets -


well said, from this old timer stock guru.

It better to learn from other people mistake (free), than own mistake which is expensive lesson...frankly I had paid many tuition fee in the last 5 yrs.

but 1 thing from my personal experience....when i reduce my greed , automatically my risk will be reduced too...hehe common sense lar.
Reply
#7
Quote:but 1 thing from my personal experience....when i reduce my greed , automatically my risk will be reduced too

did your returns decrease? Smile
Reply
#8
and I am wondering why my DBS vickers account set the sell by default to SELL CONTRA?
It's kind of trap for beginner?
Reply
#9
Good story to share, thanks. Though sometimes it makes me wonder if such stories are true, or just an attempt by the New Paper to hype something up for readership, that's all.

Nevertheless, we can take the lessons to heart and ensure we do not engage in reckless speculation like what the fellow in the article did. Purchase with a margin of safety and only after doing sufficient due diligence, and also ensure one has enough funds to tie them up for the long-term in order to receive dividends and wait for capital appreciation. Smile
My Value Investing Blog: http://sgmusicwhiz.blogspot.com/
Reply
#10
Thanks for the posting Arthur-san.

The article's a still (and always) relevant reminder not just for newbies but good for those still new to this world.

Sometimes, the temptation to chase alpha is there. I think greed/envy are hard-wired into humans. Throw in some overestimation of one's abilities together with misperception of evidence and you have the perfect recipe for disaster. This is probably very hard to overcome for most people, if they recognize it at all (After all, how many people can look themselves in the mirror and say, "I'm stupid and a loser."? This guy certainly didn't. He was already standing in a 5ft deep hole and trying to dig 1 more foot.) I think this guy's case fits that perfect storm.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 13 Guest(s)