http://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/artic...-trademark
TWG tea shop may have to change its name after court decision in trademark case
IFC Mall tea shop may have to change its name after court decision in dispute with wholesaler
PUBLISHED : Thursday, 04 December, 2014, 2:42am
UPDATED : Thursday, 04 December, 2014, 2:42am
Julie Chu
julie.chu@scmp.com
FOLLOW SCMP
SCMP
Most Popular
VIEWEDSHAREDCOMMENTED
OCCUPY CENTRAL - DAY 64: Joshua Wong announces hunger strike to call for talks with government
Stand-off ensues between protesters and police in Mong Kok
Occupy supporters and police clash as protests escalate
Beijing bans student leaders from taking trip to mainland to press for democracy
Occupy co-founders urge students to go home as they vow to surrender to police
We recommend
North Korea may send Kim Jong-un's little sister on rare business trip to South
NEWS
04 Dec 2014
North Korea may send Kim Jong-un's little sister on rare business…
Phone crooks try to scam HK$300,000 ... after mistakenly dialling the police
NEWS
05 Dec 2014
Phone crooks try to scam HK$300,000 ... after mistakenly dialling the…
Lavish Chinese wedding leaves social media stunned amid anti-corruption crackdown
NEWS
28 Nov 2014
Lavish Chinese wedding leaves social media stunned amid…
Swire Properties organises Christmas fair to raise money for Operation Santa Claus
NEWS
04 Dec 2014
Swire Properties organises Christmas fair to raise money for…
David Beckham signs joint venture with Hong Kong firm
BUSINESS
03 Dec 2014
David Beckham signs joint venture with Hong Kong firm
Chinese swimmer Sun Yang barred from Australian pools in wake of doping ban
SPORT
03 Dec 2014
Chinese swimmer Sun Yang barred from Australian pools in wake of…
Hong Kong Occupy protests student leaders consider retreatPlay Video
VIDEOS
04 Dec 2014
Hong Kong Occupy protests student leaders consider retreat
Eye on the throne, Thailand's crown prince appears to be putting his house in order
COMMENT
04 Dec 2014
Eye on the throne, Thailand's crown prince appears to be putting his…
Rewind film: Porky's (1982)
LIFESTYLE
22 Nov 2014
Rewind film: Porky's (1982)
Chinese microscopic fossil find challenges Darwin's theory
COMMENT
11 Nov 2014
Chinese microscopic fossil find challenges Darwin's theory
Why populist democracy is wrong for Hong Kong
COMMENT
02 Dec 2014
Why populist democracy is wrong for Hong Kong
China's Zhuhai airshow takes off, J-31 fighter makes debutPlay Video
VIDEOS
11 Nov 2014
China's Zhuhai airshow takes off, J-31 fighter makes debut
Hong Kong is paying the price of protest
COMMENT
01 Dec 2014
Hong Kong is paying the price of protest
Wal-Mart sacks senior executives on mainland and in Hong Kong
BUSINESS
28 Nov 2014
Wal-Mart sacks senior executives on mainland and in Hong Kong
One rule for the students, another rule for the rich
BUSINESS
19 Nov 2014
One rule for the students, another rule for the rich
Recommended by
Promotions
Your FREE copy of Home Essentials 2015
Your FREE copy of Home Essentials 2015
The TWG tea shop at the IFC Mall lost its appeal against a court decision that favoured a wholesaler with the same initials. Photo: Nora Tam
The TWG tea shop at the IFC Mall lost its appeal against a court decision that favoured a wholesaler with the same initials. Photo: Nora Tam
A luxury tea room at the upscale IFC Mall in Central may have to change its name after it lost a court appeal yesterday in a trademark dispute with a tea and coffee supplier.
The logo of Singapore-based TWG Tea Company and TWG Tea (HK) Company resembled the one used by Hong Kong's Tsit Wing Group, the Court of Appeal found. Both sides had also registered trademarks using the letters "TWG".
"From the viewpoint of an average customer, there is a high degree of similarity between the marks of [Tsit Wing] and the signs used by [TWG] at the tea salon," Court of Appeal vice-president Mr Justice Johnson Lam Man-hon wrote in the judgment, released yesterday.
"There is also a high degree of similarity between the goods for which the marks are registered and the goods and services offered by [TWG] in using the signs."
Lam, along with Mr Justice Aarif Barma and Mr Justice Ian McWalters, upheld a lower court's order for TWG to change its business name in Hong Kong.
TWG Tea has room to pursue another appeal at the Court of Final Appeal. A spokesman said the company was consulting with its legal counsel and declined to comment further on the matter.
According to the judgment, Tsit Wing started out in Hong Kong in 1932, dealing in the wholesale supply of coffee and tea products.
Since 2006, the group has registered two sets of trademarks using its initials, TWG.
The Singaporean company's main business is in operating tea shops, and it has outlets in Singapore, Kuala Lumpur, Bangkok, London, New York and Tokyo.
It began using TWG as its name, standing for The Wellness Group, in 2008. It expanded its business to Hong Kong in 2011.
In December that year, Tsit Wing launched a lawsuit after the Singaporean company started its business in the city. The group alleged that the TWG Tea logo in its goods and services was likely to cause confusion to customers.
The High Court heard from TWG Tea's lawyer that the company had a "plan B" to use another registered logo containing the acronym "TW", to which Tsit Wing had no objection.
The court ruled in July last year that TWG Tea had infringed upon Tsit Wing's trademark, and ordered it to change its name for its Hong Kong business.
This article appeared in the South China Morning Post print edition as Rival tea sellers steeped in conflict