URA rejects sole bid for Paya Lebar site
04:47 AM Nov 05, 2011SINGAPORE - The Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA) has rejected the only bid submitted by the subsidiaries of UOL Group and Singapore Land for a commercial site at Sims Avenue / Tanjong Katong Road because the price is too low.
UOL Venture Investments and SL Development had submitted a joint bid of S$529.3 million, or about S$566 psf per plot ratio, for the 99-year leasehold site.
"We are very disappointed that the tender has not been awarded. We were looking forward to a constructive role in the Government's long-term plan to decentralise commercial activities outside of CBD which will help ease business costs, reduce undue congestion and revitalise urban nodes," the consortium said in a joint statement. "The rejection is a setback to that decentralisation plan."
It said the bid had been a fair one considering "the site's technical challenges and resultant impact on layout, as well as the recent global economic turbulences and enhanced market risks".
"The rejection came as a surprise to us … As price consideration was the only reason given for the rejection, it would be useful that for future land tenders, the reserve price be made known to the public as much cost and effort are put into submissions of such a scale.''
The bid for the 2.07-ha site closed on Oct 18.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
quote mr colin tan research head of chesterton suntec international - "developers often bid at higher and higher prices in a bullish market, leading to property prices increasing in tandem. this was a missed opportunity to highlight that bullish bidding is not without risks. The system now appears to 'protect' the investment of the over the top bidders, and so lead to an upward bias in land prices.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
related news: SINGAPORE May 2011: Southeast Asia's largest property developer CapitaLand has submitted the highest bid of S$968.99 million for a vast "white site" property in the Jurong Lake district.
The Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA) closed the tender for the site, after receiving five bids in total.
The top bid also translates to about S$1,012 per square foot per plot ratio.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
seems like the govt is playing bias - protecting GLC capitaland over the top bidder (>1000psf) for sub-urban jurong lake site over UOL group of companies' bid at <600psf for city fringe paya lebar site.
are they encouraging/fueling property prices rise and inflation?
04:47 AM Nov 05, 2011SINGAPORE - The Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA) has rejected the only bid submitted by the subsidiaries of UOL Group and Singapore Land for a commercial site at Sims Avenue / Tanjong Katong Road because the price is too low.
UOL Venture Investments and SL Development had submitted a joint bid of S$529.3 million, or about S$566 psf per plot ratio, for the 99-year leasehold site.
"We are very disappointed that the tender has not been awarded. We were looking forward to a constructive role in the Government's long-term plan to decentralise commercial activities outside of CBD which will help ease business costs, reduce undue congestion and revitalise urban nodes," the consortium said in a joint statement. "The rejection is a setback to that decentralisation plan."
It said the bid had been a fair one considering "the site's technical challenges and resultant impact on layout, as well as the recent global economic turbulences and enhanced market risks".
"The rejection came as a surprise to us … As price consideration was the only reason given for the rejection, it would be useful that for future land tenders, the reserve price be made known to the public as much cost and effort are put into submissions of such a scale.''
The bid for the 2.07-ha site closed on Oct 18.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
quote mr colin tan research head of chesterton suntec international - "developers often bid at higher and higher prices in a bullish market, leading to property prices increasing in tandem. this was a missed opportunity to highlight that bullish bidding is not without risks. The system now appears to 'protect' the investment of the over the top bidders, and so lead to an upward bias in land prices.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
related news: SINGAPORE May 2011: Southeast Asia's largest property developer CapitaLand has submitted the highest bid of S$968.99 million for a vast "white site" property in the Jurong Lake district.
The Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA) closed the tender for the site, after receiving five bids in total.
The top bid also translates to about S$1,012 per square foot per plot ratio.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
seems like the govt is playing bias - protecting GLC capitaland over the top bidder (>1000psf) for sub-urban jurong lake site over UOL group of companies' bid at <600psf for city fringe paya lebar site.
are they encouraging/fueling property prices rise and inflation?