01-11-2013, 02:28 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-11-2013, 02:31 PM by specuvestor.)
I don't have thoughts about the has-been GBP
IMHO, contrary to common perceptions, the Maastricht treaty structured the EUR sandbox very well. People blame it on lack of fiscal union, lack of penalties etc. For sure fiscal union would be preferred but IMHO is not a prerequisite as monetary policies can be independent from politics, just as the US states and the Federal Govt but with a difference. Texans will bail out New Yorkers because they are Americans. Europeans yet to reach this enlightened self-interest stage yet.
If we look back, the primary problem was 2 folds: Germany merger and end of Warsaw Pact. The huge fiscal deficit in Germany set a precedent that the Maastricht treaty can be breached. The over zealous expansion of Eurozone into ex Warsaw states was for political reasons even when the economic prerequisites were not met yet. The catalyst turn out to be Greece who fudged their numbers via GS structuring, just to join the EU.
With the stabilisation of the crisis and a more pragmatic ECB president Draghi vs the idealistic Trichet, I think Eurozone will recover. The structural issues of welfare state is there and I think Eurozone will continue to be the old man of the world with old money who sucks on execution. Definitely very painful for the young people now looking for job. But for the greater good which the forefathers of the Eurozone envisoned, together they will be a formidable force in the global economy to balance up USD and RMB.
IMHO, contrary to common perceptions, the Maastricht treaty structured the EUR sandbox very well. People blame it on lack of fiscal union, lack of penalties etc. For sure fiscal union would be preferred but IMHO is not a prerequisite as monetary policies can be independent from politics, just as the US states and the Federal Govt but with a difference. Texans will bail out New Yorkers because they are Americans. Europeans yet to reach this enlightened self-interest stage yet.
If we look back, the primary problem was 2 folds: Germany merger and end of Warsaw Pact. The huge fiscal deficit in Germany set a precedent that the Maastricht treaty can be breached. The over zealous expansion of Eurozone into ex Warsaw states was for political reasons even when the economic prerequisites were not met yet. The catalyst turn out to be Greece who fudged their numbers via GS structuring, just to join the EU.
With the stabilisation of the crisis and a more pragmatic ECB president Draghi vs the idealistic Trichet, I think Eurozone will recover. The structural issues of welfare state is there and I think Eurozone will continue to be the old man of the world with old money who sucks on execution. Definitely very painful for the young people now looking for job. But for the greater good which the forefathers of the Eurozone envisoned, together they will be a formidable force in the global economy to balance up USD and RMB.
(01-11-2013, 02:11 PM)arthur Wrote: Thanks Specuvestor.
What are your thoughts on EUR and GBP?
Frankly, I am having some reservation on EUR, being itself a supranational currency, which enjoys monetary union but no fiscal union.
Ultimately, I can't see its future without fiscal union having one Monetary Central Bank setting limits for all EU countries.
Having some European friends who are still lambasting the socialist policies of their nations, I doubt Europe will get out of this crisis as fast as they proclaimed.
Some Europeans are calling this a lost generation for their youngsters. Young graduates who can't find a job. No experience, can't migrate. Sad but true.
Before you speak, listen. Before you write, think. Before you spend, earn. Before you invest, investigate. Before you criticize, wait. Before you pray, forgive. Before you quit, try. Before you retire, save. Before you die, give. –William A. Ward
Think Asset-Business-Structure (ABS)
Think Asset-Business-Structure (ABS)